Stay in the Loop

Get ahead in the world of co-ownership with our exclusive newsletters, guides, and new property alerts! Subscribe now to stay updated and we’ll connect you with trusted co-ownership providers tailored to your needs.

December 2023

Is it Better to Buy or Rent a Vacation Home?

The Great Vacation Home Dilemma

The question of whether it’s better to buy or rent a vacation home crosses the mind of most holidaymakers. Yes, renting gives you an element of flexibility, but you’re effectively paying your hard-earned money into the pocket of the vacation home’s owner. The idea of buying a second home, on the other hand, can feel exciting and nerve-wracking in equal measure! Having a home away from home is a total dream come true, but what about the ongoing financial implications of home ownership, after you’ve invested in the property?

Buy or Rent a Vacation Home

Buying vs. renting…it’s a real conundrum and the decision requires careful consideration. To help you decide what’s right for your personal circumstances, we’ve rounded up the key factors that can guide your choice. We tackle this subject from a co-ownership aspect, looking at buying a co-owned property compared to renting a vacation home. 

Investment vs. expense

When pondering the purchase of a vacation home, it's important to weigh it up as an investment. A second home is an asset that may appreciate in value over time, potentially providing a source of passive income if you choose to rent it out when you're not using it.

On the flip side, renting a vacation home is a straightforward expense that provides you with a temporary escape without long-term financial commitment. Renting ticks the vacation box but it’s money you’ll never get back.

Frequency of use

Consider how often you plan to use the vacation home. If you like frequent getaways throughout the year, owning or co-owning a vacation home may be more practical. It provides the convenience of having your own space - always ready and exactly how you like it.

However, if your visits are sporadic and you're uncertain about committing to a particular location, renting gives you the flexibility to explore different destinations without the commitment of ownership.

Location, location, location!

The location of your vacation home plays a major role in your decision-making process. Do you have a particular spot that’s close to your heart or offers the perfect environment for relaxation? If you've found your dream destination, buying a vacation property might be the way to go. You can create lasting memories in a place that feels like a second home.

On the other hand, if you prefer variety and you're open to exploring different destinations, renting provides the freedom to experience diverse areas without being tied to one place. 

The financial aspect

Buying a vacation home involves not only the upfront cost but also ongoing expenses like property taxes, maintenance, and utilities. It's essential to calculate these costs and ensure they align with your budget. The joy of co-ownership is that you can share these costs with your co-owners, but as an independent owner, you would be solely responsible for all expenses.

Owning a property means that you can rent it out when you’re not using it, so you might like to factor in the potential of rental income.

In contrast, renting a vacation home involves a fixed cost for the duration of your stay, but as a guest and not an owner, there is of course no possibility of generating any income.

Maintenance and hassle

Owning a vacation home independently entails the responsibility of maintenance. From repairs to landscaping, the upkeep can be demanding, both in terms of time and money.

If you're not prepared for the additional workload, co-owning or renting might be the less stressful option. Co-ownership providers take care of all the maintenance duties, allowing co-owners to fully enjoy their stay without the worry of painting, gardening, or pool care! Co-owners can fully relax on vacation, in the same way that renters do. 

Sense of ownership vs. flexibility

Nothing beats the feeling of owning a vacation home.  It's a place that's yours, and each time you visit you add to a bank of happy memories! By returning to the same place, you form a strong connection to both your second home and the local community.

Renting, on the other hand, offers the freedom to choose a new destination for each vacation, potentially catering to your changing preferences and circumstances.

The emotional factor

Buying a vacation home isn’t just about dollars and cents; it's a decision influenced by emotions. The thought of having a place to call your own, a retreat where you've made precious memories, is a tempting prospect that’s not to be underestimated.

A vacation rental serves its purpose as a short-term getaway, but the connection you feel to the property is never as strong as a second home that’s yours. So, if the emotional aspect strongly resonates with you, owning a vacation home might well be the right choice.

Weighing up the pros and cons

The decision of whether it’s better to buy or rent a vacation home ultimately hinges on your unique preferences and financial circumstances. Buying offers a sense of ownership, potential investment benefits, and the joy of a second home, while renting provides flexibility and the ability to explore different destinations. 

The perfect solution

For decades it hasn’t been easy to decide between buying or renting, but things have become so much easier since modern co-ownership entered the vacation realm!  Closing the gap between affordable vacationing and vacation home ownership, co-ownership allows you to buy a second home you feel proud of, afford the ongoing running costs by sharing them with fellow co-owners, and enjoy many years of happy family vacations in a much-loved destination.

Kocomo can help you learn more about co-ownership, compare providers, and find a spectacular co-owned vacation home.

Link copied to clipboard!

Kocomo Newsletter

Subscribe for exclusive, up-to-the-minute news on co-ownership.